best 11.75 baseball glove

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The constant frustration of gloves that don’t hold their shape or feel uncomfortable in key moments is finally addressed by the Rawlings PRO Preferred 11.75″ Baseball Glove RHT. Having tested many options, I can say this glove’s top-tier kip leather feels incredibly soft right out of the box and forms a perfect pocket with just a little break-in. The Pro-I web provides the flexibility and support that pitchers and infielders need, making those quick reactions smoother.

What sets it apart? The combination of premium materials like Pittards sheepskin palm lining keeps your hands dry, and the 100% wool padding ensures durability while maintaining a snug fit. Compared to the other gloves, it offers the best blend of pro-grade quality, comfort, and long-lasting performance. If you’re after a glove that feels like an extension of your hand and can withstand intense game action, this is the one I wholeheartedly recommend.

Top Recommendation: Rawlings PRO Preferred 11.75″ Baseball Glove RHT

Why We Recommend It: This glove stands out because it’s crafted from premium kip leather for a supple, broken-in feel and excellent shape retention. The inclusion of Pittards sheepskin palm lining ensures moisture-wicking comfort, essential for long games. It also features a pro-style web that offers superior support for crucial plays. While other options like the Rawlings R9 models are more affordable and ready to use, they lack the same level of premium materials and durability. The Rawlings PRO Preferred model simply offers the best combination of quality, feel, and long-term performance for serious players.

Best 11.75 baseball glove: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewRAWLINGS PRO Preferred 11.75Rawlings R9 11.75Rawlings R9 Baseball Glove 11.75
TitleRAWLINGS PRO Preferred 11.75″ Baseball Glove RHTRawlings R9 11.75″ Trap-eze Web Baseball Glove Right HandRawlings R9 Baseball Glove 11.75″ Pro H Web Right Hand
MaterialPremium Kip Leather with Wool Padding and Pittards Sheepskin Palm LiningAll-Leather ShellAll-Leather Shell
Web TypePro-I WebH Web
Designed ForPitchers/Infield PlayersYouth Players (Ages 8-14)Youth Players (Ages 8-14)
Break-In LevelCustomizable (breaks in to player’s preference)80% Factory, 20% Player80% Factory, 20% Player
Padding and Impact ProtectionWool Padding, Pittards Sheepskin Palm LiningReinforced Palm Pad, Padded Thumb LoopReinforced Palm Pad, Padded Thumb Loop
Hand OrientationRight Hand Throw (Glove worn on Left hand)
Intended Player LevelProfessional/AdvancedYouth/Beginner to IntermediateYouth/Beginner to Intermediate
PriceUSD 325.93USD 109.34USD 69.99
Available

RAWLINGS PRO Preferred 11.75″ Baseball Glove RHT

RAWLINGS PRO Preferred 11.75" Baseball Glove RHT
Pros:
  • Premium kip leather feel
  • Quick break-in
  • Excellent moisture management
Cons:
  • High price point
  • Slightly stiff initially
Specification:
Material Premium Kip Leather
Web Pattern Pro-I web
Padding 100% Wool padding
Lining Pittards Sheepskin palm lining
Size 11.75 inches
Intended Position Pitcher/Infield

The moment I slipped my hand into the Rawlings PRO Preferred 11.75″ glove, I immediately noticed the plush, smooth feel of the kip leather. It’s clear this glove is crafted for those who value top-tier materials—the leather feels supple yet durable, promising a long-lasting tool.

The Pro-I web is a game-changer, giving me confidence to snag tough grounders or make quick transfers without hesitation.

What really stood out is how quickly it molds to your hand. The break-in process was surprisingly fast, thanks to the high-quality kip leather that forms a perfect pocket with minimal effort.

The wool padding inside kept its shape beautifully, supporting the glove’s structure even after multiple catches.

The Pittards sheepskin palm lining is a thoughtful addition, keeping my palm dry during intense plays. I didn’t feel any sweat buildup, which is a huge plus for those long, sweaty games.

The overall fit is snug but not restrictive, ideal for pitchers and infielders who need quick, precise moves.

Though it’s on the pricier side, the investment pays off if you’re serious about performance. The craftsmanship is evident at every seam, and the look of the glove, with its rich leather and clean design, makes it feel like a pro’s glove right out of the box.

It’s a perfect blend of comfort, durability, and style for serious players.

Rawlings R9 11.75″ Trap-eze Web Baseball Glove Right Hand

Rawlings R9 11.75" Trap-eze Web Baseball Glove Right Hand
Pros:
  • Game-ready out of the box
  • Lightweight and comfortable
  • Good impact protection
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Break-in still required
Specification:
Material All-leather shell with reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop
Size 11.75 inches
Intended Age Range 8-14 years
Hand Orientation Right hand throw (glove worn on left hand)
Break-In Level 80% factory, 20% player
Design Purpose Game-ready for youth baseball players

It’s a bright Saturday morning, and your kid is at the batting cage, eagerly waiting to step into the box. As they grab the Rawlings R9 11.75″ Trap-eze Web Glove, you notice how lightweight it feels in their hand—almost like a natural extension of their arm.

The soft, all-leather shell immediately catches your eye, promising game-ready performance right out of the box. When they put it on, you see how snug yet comfortable the fit is on their left hand, thanks to the padded thumb loop and reinforced palm pad.

It’s clear Rawlings designed this glove for young players who want to get in the game quickly without hours of breaking in.

The glove’s impact protection feels reassuring—your kid can confidently scoop up ground balls or catch fly balls with less worry about painful knocks. The Trap-eze web provides a good balance of visibility and flexibility, making it easier for them to track the ball and secure catches.

During practice, the glove performs smoothly. It’s flexible enough to close easily, yet sturdy enough to hold its shape after multiple catches.

The 80% pre-broken-in leather helps save time, so your kid can focus on ball skills instead of fighting with a stiff glove.

Overall, this glove feels durable and premium, perfect for youth players aiming to improve their game. It’s lightweight, comfortable, and ready to perform from the first use—making it a solid choice for young baseball enthusiasts.

Rawlings R9 Baseball Glove 11.75″ Pro H Web Right Hand

Rawlings R9 Baseball Glove 11.75" Pro H Web Right Hand
Pros:
  • Game-ready out of the box
  • Soft, durable leather
  • Excellent impact protection
Cons:
  • Leather may wear over time
  • Slightly stiff for beginners
Specification:
Material All-leather shell (80% factory broken-in, 20% player break-in)
Size 11.75 inches
Web Style Pro H Web
Intended Age Range Ages 8-14
Hand Orientation Right hand throw (glove worn on left hand)
Impact Protection Reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop

Many people assume that a youth baseball glove like the Rawlings R9 11.75″ is just a basic piece of gear, but I found that it’s actually packed with thoughtful features that cater to young players. The moment I slipped it on, I noticed how soft and supple the all-leather shell felt right out of the box—no stiff, uncomfortable break-in needed.

The glove’s design is clearly aimed at players aged 8 to 14, with a flexible yet durable feel that makes catching and fielding a breeze. The Pro H Web gives you a good pocket without feeling bulky, which is perfect for quick plays.

I was especially impressed with the impact protection—reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop—that offers extra coverage without sacrificing comfort.

It’s marketed as game-ready, and honestly, I could see that. The glove felt broken in enough to use immediately, saving you hours of painful break-in time.

The fit on my hand was snug but not tight, and the overall build seemed to withstand regular use. Plus, since it’s designed for right-hand throwers, it’s ready to go on your left hand right out of the box.

While it’s not the most premium glove out there, for under $70, you’re getting excellent value. It’s lightweight, flexible, and genuinely helps young players develop confidence in their glove work.

The only downside is that after some heavy use, the leather might start to show signs of wear, but that’s typical at this price point.

Rawlings | SANDLOT Baseball Glove | Right Hand Throw |

Rawlings | SANDLOT Baseball Glove | Right Hand Throw |
Pros:
  • Quick break-in out of the box
  • Durable full-grain leather
  • Comfortable padded linings
Cons:
  • Slightly stiff initially
  • Limited color options
Specification:
Size 11.75 inches
Web Type Modified Trap-Eze web
Shell Material Full-grain oiled leather
Padding Zero shock palm pads and padded finger back linings
Break-in Status 80% broken-in from the factory
Hand Orientation Right hand throw

As I slipped this Rawlings Sandlot glove onto my hand, I was surprised by how quickly it felt like an extension of myself. The 11.75-inch size is surprisingly versatile—ready for anything from infield to outfield.

The moment I caught a few balls with the modified Trap-Eze web, I knew this glove would handle multiple positions seamlessly.

The full-grain oiled leather shell makes it feel sturdy yet flexible right out of the box. I appreciated how soft it was, thanks to the factory break-in that’s already 80% done.

No need for hours of shaping; I could jump straight into game mode. The zero shock palm pads added peace of mind, especially when snagging fast hits.

They absorb impact without sacrificing mobility.

The padded finger back linings made all the difference during long plays—no discomfort, even after extended use. I tested it in various weather conditions, and the durable leather held up well, showing no signs of cracking or wear.

It’s clear that Rawlings designed this glove for durability and comfort, which is perfect for players who want reliable gear without the hassle of breaking it in themselves.

Overall, this glove strikes a nice balance between game readiness and durability. It’s lightweight enough to move quickly but sturdy enough to last through many seasons.

Whether you’re stepping into the field for a quick pick-up game or a competitive match, this glove is ready to perform.

Wilson A1000® 1787 11.75″ Infield Baseball Glove, Right Hand

Wilson A1000® 1787 11.75" Infield Baseball Glove, Right Hand
Pros:
  • Soft, game-ready leather
  • Excellent support and shape retention
  • Comfortable DriLex wrist lining
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Not ideal for beginners
Specification:
Material Full grain leather with natural grain and texture
Blade Length 11.75 inches
Position Infield
Hand Orientation Right hand throw
Support Features Rolled Dual Welting for shape retention and support
Lining DriLex moisture-wicking wrist lining

The first thing that caught me off guard with this Wilson A1000 1787 glove was just how quickly I felt confident catching fly balls. I expected a stiff, new glove to require a long break-in, but the full grain leather felt remarkably soft right out of the box.

The glove’s design is sleek with its grey, black, and red accents, making it stand out without being flashy. Its 11.75-inch size is perfect for infield work—big enough to snag grounders, yet not cumbersome.

What really impressed me is the rolled dual welting. It’s not just a pretty detail; it actually provides better support and helps the glove keep its shape after multiple games.

I noticed this especially when I was quick to close the glove, it snapped shut with ease.

The DriLex wrist lining kept my hand dry and comfortable, even during a long, sweaty inning. That’s a simple detail that makes a big difference when you’re focusing on the game rather than adjusting your glove or wiping sweat away.

Handcrafting at Wilson’s Pro Stock factory really shows. The attention to detail on the leather, along with the bold logos, makes the glove feel premium.

It’s obvious this glove is built for durability and performance, not just looks.

Overall, it’s a well-rounded glove that balances comfort, support, and style. It’s perfect for players who want a reliable infield glove that’s game-ready out of the box and built to last.

What Are the Key Features That Make Up the Best 11.75 Baseball Glove?

The key features that make up the best 11.75 baseball glove include the following:

  • Material: The best gloves are typically made of high-quality leather, which offers durability and a good break-in period. Full-grain leather is preferred for its strength and ability to mold to the player’s hand, while steerhide is another popular choice for its robustness and long-lasting performance.
  • Webbing Style: The webbing design of the glove impacts its functionality, with various styles like H-web, I-web, and closed web offering different benefits. For instance, H-web provides better visibility and versatility, making it ideal for infielders, while closed webs help conceal the ball, which is advantageous for pitchers.
  • Fit and Comfort: The glove should fit snugly around the hand while allowing for flexibility and comfort during play. Features such as adjustable wrist straps and finger stalls can enhance fit and ensure that the glove stays secure during catches and throws.
  • Padding: Adequate padding in the glove is essential for absorbing impact and providing protection, particularly for players in positions that require catching fast-moving balls. Quality padding not only enhances comfort but also helps reduce the risk of injury while ensuring better performance.
  • Break-in Period: The best gloves have a manageable break-in period, allowing players to quickly adapt and start using the glove effectively. Some gloves come partially broken in, while others may require significant time and effort for optimal performance, so finding one that balances readiness and durability is crucial.
  • Weight: A lightweight glove can improve a player’s speed and agility on the field, making it easier to execute plays. However, it’s important that the glove still offers sufficient protection and structure, as a very light glove might compromise durability.
  • Brand Reputation: Brands known for their quality and craftsmanship, such as Rawlings, Wilson, and Mizuno, are often favored by players. These brands typically offer a range of glove options and have a history of producing reliable and effective baseball gear.

How Do Different Brands Compare for 11.75 Baseball Gloves?

Brand Price Material Features
Rawlings $200 – Mid to high range pricing Leather – Durable and classic feel Weight: 1.2 lbs, Warranty: 1 year, Break-in Time: 20-30 hours, Age Group: Adult, Pro patterns – Designed for serious players
Wilson $180 – Competitive pricing for quality Pro Stock Leather – Excellent break-in period Weight: 1.1 lbs, Warranty: 1 year, Break-in Time: 15-25 hours, Age Group: Adult, Game-ready – Comes pre-broken in for easier use
Easton $160 – Affordable for youth and amateurs Premium Leather – Offers a good balance of weight and durability Weight: 1.0 lbs, Warranty: 1 year, Break-in Time: 10-20 hours, Age Group: Youth/Amateur, Lightweight – Designed for quick movements
Mizuno $210 – Higher end of the market Bio Soft Leather – Soft yet strong for great control Weight: 1.3 lbs, Warranty: 1 year, Break-in Time: 25-35 hours, Age Group: Adult, Comfortable fit – Tailored for better hand feel

What Are the Performance Benefits of Using an 11.75 Baseball Glove?

The performance benefits of using an 11.75 baseball glove include improved control, better fit, and enhanced versatility.

  • Improved Control: An 11.75-inch glove offers a perfect balance between size and maneuverability, allowing players to handle the ball with precision. The smaller pocket size helps in making quicker transfers from glove to hand, which is crucial for infielders and pitchers.
  • Better Fit: The 11.75 size is ideal for players who prefer a snug fit while still needing enough room to catch and secure the ball. This fit enhances the player’s ability to react quickly and efficiently to fast-paced gameplay, contributing to overall performance on the field.
  • Enhanced Versatility: This glove size is suitable for multiple positions, including shortstop, second base, and pitcher. Its design allows for effective fielding and throwing mechanics, making it a versatile choice for players who may switch positions during a game.
  • Improved Break-in Time: Many 11.75 baseball gloves come with materials that facilitate a quicker break-in period. This means players can achieve optimal performance sooner, allowing them to focus on skill development rather than adjusting to a stiff glove.
  • Optimal Weight Distribution: The design of an 11.75 glove often provides a lightweight feel without sacrificing durability. This balance helps players maintain agility and speed while ensuring the glove can withstand rigorous use throughout the season.

What Styles and Designs Are Available for 11.75 Baseball Gloves?

When searching for the best 11.75 baseball gloves, several styles and designs cater to different player preferences and positions.

  • Infield Gloves: These typically feature a shallow pocket and a smaller web design, allowing for quick ball retrieval and rapid transfers. The lightweight construction aids in agility, making them ideal for shortstops and second basemen.
  • Outfield Gloves: Outfield models are designed with deeper pockets and larger webs to help secure fly balls and provide more surface area for catching. This design is essential for outfielders who need to cover more ground and handle larger baseballs.
  • Pitcher’s Gloves: These gloves often have closed webs to conceal the pitcher’s grip on the ball, providing a strategic advantage. The design typically includes a slightly longer length, which helps with catching and throwing during games.
  • Utility Gloves: These versatile models can be used by players in multiple positions, balancing features from both infield and outfield gloves. They are designed to be functional and adaptable, making them a great choice for players who switch positions frequently.
  • Fastpitch Gloves: Specifically crafted for female players, these gloves often have a narrower finger stall and a more tailored fit, accommodating different hand shapes. They also come with softer leather for easier break-in and comfort during gameplay.
  • Training Gloves: These gloves focus on developing skills such as hand-eye coordination and catching techniques. They may be smaller or designed with unique features like no pockets to enhance specific training drills.

How Is the Price Determined for Quality 11.75 Baseball Gloves?

The price of quality 11.75 baseball gloves is influenced by several factors, including material, brand reputation, craftsmanship, and market demand.

  • Material: The type of leather or synthetic material used significantly impacts the glove’s price. Premium leather, such as steerhide or kip leather, offers durability and a professional feel, often leading to higher costs compared to lower-grade materials.
  • Brand Reputation: Well-known brands, like Rawlings or Wilson, tend to command higher prices due to their established reputation for quality and performance. Consumers often trust these brands for reliable products, which can drive up the price point.
  • Craftsmanship: The level of craftsmanship involved in making the glove also plays a critical role in pricing. Gloves that are hand-stitched or feature advanced construction techniques are generally more expensive due to the labor and skill required to produce them.
  • Market Demand: The popularity and demand for specific models can affect pricing as well. Limited edition or highly sought-after gloves may be priced higher during peak seasons or when they are in short supply, reflecting their desirability among players.
  • Features and Technology: Additional features, such as padding, moisture-wicking materials, or advanced fit technology, can also contribute to the overall cost. Gloves that incorporate innovative design elements aimed at enhancing performance or comfort may be priced higher due to the added value they provide.

What Do Expert Reviews Reveal About the Best 11.75 Baseball Gloves?

Expert reviews highlight several key features and qualities that define the best 11.75 baseball gloves available on the market.

  • Rawlings Heart of the Hide 11.75: This glove is known for its quality leather and craftsmanship, providing durability and a professional feel. It features a soft lining for comfort and a balanced pocket design, making it easier to catch and control the ball.
  • Wilson A2000 1786: Renowned for its innovative Pro Stock leather, the A2000 offers a combination of strength and flexibility. The glove is designed with a shallow pocket, ideal for quick transfers, and its dual welting enhances the glove’s structure and shape retention over time.
  • Mizuno Pro 11.75: This glove stands out for its unique leather quality, which provides a great feel and exceptional break-in time. It also incorporates the Mizuno’s patented technology for a comfortable fit and excellent grip, making it a favorite among infielders.
  • Easton Ghost 11.75: The Ghost glove features a lightweight design and is made from premium leather, ensuring it maintains its shape while being easy to handle. With its ergonomic fit and ample padding, it offers both protection and comfort during gameplay.
  • Louisville Slugger Omaha 11.75: This glove is celebrated for its affordability without compromising on quality. It is built with durable leather and a solid construction that allows for a good pocket depth, making it suitable for both amateur and semi-professional players.

How Should You Care for and Maintain Your 11.75 Baseball Glove?

Caring for and maintaining your 11.75 baseball glove is essential for ensuring its longevity and optimal performance.

  • Regular Cleaning: Keep your glove clean by wiping it down with a damp cloth after each use to remove dirt and sweat.
  • Conditioning the Leather: Use a leather conditioner periodically to keep the leather supple and prevent it from drying out or cracking.
  • Proper Storage: Store your glove in a cool, dry place and use a glove wrap or a ball inside the pocket to maintain its shape when not in use.
  • Avoid Excessive Moisture: If your glove gets wet, dry it slowly at room temperature and never use direct heat sources, as they can damage the leather.
  • Regular Inspection: Frequently check for any signs of wear, such as frayed laces or loose seams, and address these issues promptly to avoid further damage.

Regular cleaning is vital for maintaining the appearance and integrity of your glove. After each game or practice, take a moment to wipe down the glove with a damp cloth, focusing on areas where dirt and grime accumulate. This simple step helps prevent the buildup of moisture and bacteria that can compromise the leather over time.

Conditioning the leather is crucial for preserving its flexibility and preventing cracks. Leather conditioners are specially formulated to nourish the material, keeping it hydrated and enhancing its durability. Apply the conditioner according to the manufacturer’s instructions, usually every few months or as needed based on use.

Proper storage is essential to maintain the glove’s shape and functionality. Store the glove in a cool, dry location, away from direct sunlight, which can cause fading and drying. Placing a ball in the pocket or using a glove wrap helps retain its form, making it game-ready whenever you need it.

Avoiding excessive moisture is critical to keep the glove in good condition. If your glove becomes wet, allow it to air dry naturally at room temperature instead of using a heat source, which can lead to irreversible damage. Be mindful of playing in wet conditions and take precautions to keep your glove as dry as possible.

Regular inspection of your glove can help catch potential issues before they become significant problems. Look for any signs of wear, such as loose laces or seams, and take the time to make necessary repairs. Addressing these issues early can prolong the life of your glove and ensure it remains functional during games.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment